Bill Title: To prohibit manufactured homes park operators, condominium associations, neighborhood associations, and landlords from restricting the display of blue star banners, gold star banners, and other service flags, and to prohibit manufactured homes park operators and landlords from restricting the display of the United States flag.
Spectrum: Bipartisan Bill
Status: (Introduced - Dead) 2011-05-24 - Committee Report - S
[HB189 Detail]Download: Ohio-2011-HB189-Comm_Sub.html
As Reported by the House Financial Institutions, Housing and Urban Development Committee
| 129th General Assembly | | Regular Session | | 2011-2012 |
| |
Representatives Coley, DeGeeter
Cosponsors:
Representatives O'Brien, Garland, Butler, Yuko, Martin, Murray, Slaby, Beck, Fende, Pillich, Blair, Combs, Ruhl, Schuring, Dovilla, Adams, J., Phillips, Okey, Antonio, Carey, Derickson, McKenney, Brenner, Goyal, Stautberg, Foley, Slesnick, Ashford, Gentile
A BILL
| To amend sections 3733.11, 5301.072, and 5311.191 and | 1 |
|
to enact section 5321.131 of the Revised Code to | 2 |
|
prohibit manufactured homes park operators, | 3 |
|
condominium associations, neighborhood | 4 |
|
associations, and landlords from restricting the | 5 |
|
display of blue star banners, gold star banners, | 6 |
|
and other service flags, and to prohibit | 7 |
|
manufactured homes park operators and landlords | 8 |
|
from restricting the display of the United States | 9 |
BE IT ENACTED BY THE GENERAL ASSEMBLY OF THE STATE OF OHIO:
| Section 1. That sections 3733.11, 5301.072, and 5311.191 be | 11 |
|
amended and section 5321.131 of the Revised Code be enacted to | 12 |
|
read as follows: | 13 |
| Sec. 3733.11. (A)(1) The park operator shall offer each home | 14 |
|
owner a written rental agreement for a manufactured home park lot | 15 |
|
for a term of one year or more that contains terms essentially the | 16 |
|
same as any alternative month-to-month rental agreement offered to | 17 |
|
current and prospective tenants and owners. The park operator | 18 |
|
shall offer the minimum one-year rental agreement to the owner | 19 |
|
prior to installation of the home in the manufactured home park | 20 |
|
or, if the home is in the manufactured home park, prior to the | 21 |
|
expiration of the owner's existing rental agreement. | 22 |
| (2) The park operator shall deliver the offer to the owner by | 23 |
|
certified mail, return receipt requested, or in person. If the | 24 |
|
park operator delivers the offer to the owner in person, the owner | 25 |
|
shall complete a return showing receipt of the offer. If the owner | 26 |
|
does not accept the offer, the park operator is discharged from | 27 |
|
any obligation to make any further such offers. If the owner | 28 |
|
accepts the offer, the park operator shall, at the expiration of | 29 |
|
each successive rental agreement, offer the owner another rental | 30 |
|
agreement, for a term that is mutually agreed upon, and that | 31 |
|
contains terms essentially the same as the alternative | 32 |
|
month-to-month agreement. The park operator shall deliver | 33 |
|
subsequent rental offers by ordinary mail or personal delivery. If | 34 |
|
the park operator sells the manufactured home park to another | 35 |
|
manufactured home park operator, the purchaser is bound by the | 36 |
|
rental agreements entered into by the purchaser's predecessor. | 37 |
| (3) If the park operator sells the manufactured home park for | 38 |
|
a use other than as a manufactured home park, the park operator | 39 |
|
shall give each tenant and owner a written notification by | 40 |
|
certified mail, return receipt requested, or by handing it to the | 41 |
|
tenant or owner in person. If the park operator delivers the | 42 |
|
notification in person, the recipient shall complete a return | 43 |
|
showing receipt of the notification. This notification shall | 44 |
|
contain notice of the sale of the manufactured home park, and | 45 |
|
notice of the date by which the tenant or owner shall vacate. The | 46 |
|
date by which the tenant shall vacate shall be at least one | 47 |
|
hundred twenty days after receipt of the written notification, and | 48 |
|
the date by which the owner shall vacate shall be at least one | 49 |
|
hundred eighty days after receipt of the written notification. | 50 |
| (B) A park operator shall fully disclose in writing all fees, | 51 |
|
charges, assessments, including rental fees, and rules prior to a | 52 |
|
tenant or owner executing a rental agreement and assuming | 53 |
|
occupancy in the manufactured home park. No fees, charges, | 54 |
|
assessments, or rental fees so disclosed may be increased nor | 55 |
|
rules changed by a park operator without specifying the date of | 56 |
|
implementation of the changed fees, charges, assessments, rental | 57 |
|
fees, or rules, which date shall be not less than thirty days | 58 |
|
after written notice of the change and its effective date to all | 59 |
|
tenants or owners in the manufactured home park, and no fee, | 60 |
|
charge, assessment, or rental fee shall be increased during the | 61 |
|
term of any tenant's or owner's rental agreement. Failure on the | 62 |
|
part of the park operator to fully disclose all fees, charges, or | 63 |
|
assessments shall prevent the park operator from collecting the | 64 |
|
undisclosed fees, charges, or assessments. If a tenant or owner | 65 |
|
refuses to pay any undisclosed fees, charges, or assessments, the | 66 |
|
refusal shall not be used by the park operator as a cause for | 67 |
|
eviction in any court. | 68 |
| (C)(1) A park operator shall promulgate rules governing the | 69 |
|
rental or occupancy of a lot in the manufactured home park. The | 70 |
|
rules shall not be unreasonable, arbitrary, or capricious. A copy | 71 |
|
of the rules and any amendments to them shall be delivered by the | 72 |
|
park operator to the tenant or owner prior to signing the rental | 73 |
|
agreement. A copy of the rules and any amendments to them shall be | 74 |
|
posted in a conspicuous place upon the manufactured home park | 75 |
|
grounds. | 76 |
| (2) No park operator shall include any restriction in a | 77 |
|
rental agreement, or otherwise prohibit on a tenant's or owner's | 78 |
|
rental property, either of the following: | 79 |
| (a) The display of the flag of the United States if the flag | 80 |
|
is displayed in accordance with any of the following: | 81 |
| (i) The patriotic customs set forth in 4 U.S.C.A. 5-10, as | 82 |
|
amended, governing the display and use of the flag of the United | 83 |
|
States; | 84 |
| (ii) Federal law, state law, or any local ordinance or | 85 |
|
resolution; | 86 |
| (iii) A proclamation of the president of the United States or | 87 |
|
the governor of the state. | 88 |
| (b) The display of a service flag approved by the United | 89 |
|
States secretary of defense for display in a window of the | 90 |
|
residence of a member of the immediate family of an individual | 91 |
|
serving in the armed forces of the United States. A service flag | 92 |
|
includes a blue star banner, a gold star banner, and any other | 93 |
|
flag the secretary of defense designates as a service flag. | 94 |
| (3) Any violation of this division is against public policy | 95 |
|
and unenforceable. Any provision of a rental agreement that | 96 |
|
violates this division is an unconscionable term under section | 97 |
|
3733.16 of the Revised Code. | 98 |
| (D) No park operator shall require an owner to purchase from | 99 |
|
the park operator any personal property. The park operator may | 100 |
|
determine by rule the style or quality of skirting, equipment for | 101 |
|
tying down homes, manufactured or mobile home accessories, or | 102 |
|
other equipment to be purchased by an owner from a vendor of the | 103 |
|
owner's choosing, provided that the equipment is readily available | 104 |
|
to the owner. Any such equipment shall be installed in accordance | 105 |
|
with the manufactured home park rules. | 106 |
| (E) No park operator shall charge any owner who chooses to | 107 |
|
install an electric or gas appliance in a home an additional fee | 108 |
|
solely on the basis of the installation, unless the installation | 109 |
|
is performed by the park operator at the request of the owner, nor | 110 |
|
shall the park operator restrict the installation, service, or | 111 |
|
maintenance of the appliance, restrict the ingress or egress of | 112 |
|
repairpersons to the manufactured home park for the purpose of | 113 |
|
installation, service, or maintenance of the appliance, nor | 114 |
|
restrict the making of any interior improvement in a home, if the | 115 |
|
installation or improvement is in compliance with applicable | 116 |
|
building codes and other provisions of law and if adequate utility | 117 |
|
services are available for the installation or improvement. | 118 |
| (F) No park operator shall require a tenant to lease or an | 119 |
|
owner to purchase a manufactured or mobile home from the park | 120 |
|
operator or any specific person as a condition of or prerequisite | 121 |
|
to entering into a rental agreement. | 122 |
| (G) No park operator shall require an owner to use the | 123 |
|
services of the park operator or any other specific person for | 124 |
|
installation of the manufactured or mobile home on the residential | 125 |
|
premises or for the performance of any service. | 126 |
| (H) No park operator shall: | 127 |
| (1) Deny any owner the right to sell the owner's manufactured | 128 |
|
home within the manufactured home park if the owner gives the park | 129 |
|
operator ten days' notice of the intention to sell the home; | 130 |
| (2) Require the owner to remove the home from the | 131 |
|
manufactured home park solely on the basis of the sale of the | 132 |
|
home; | 133 |
| (3) Unreasonably refuse to enter into a rental agreement with | 134 |
|
a purchaser of a home located within the operator's manufactured | 135 |
|
home park; | 136 |
| (4) Charge any tenant or owner any fee, charge, or | 137 |
|
assessment, including a rental fee, that is not set forth in the | 138 |
|
rental agreement or, if the rental agreement is oral, is not set | 139 |
|
forth in a written disclosure given to the tenant or owner prior | 140 |
|
to the tenant or owner entering into a rental agreement; | 141 |
| (5) Charge any owner any fee, charge, or assessment because | 142 |
|
of the transfer of ownership of a home or because a home is moved | 143 |
|
out of or into the manufactured home park, except a charge for the | 144 |
|
actual costs and expenses that are incurred by the park operator | 145 |
|
in moving the home out of or into the manufactured home park, or | 146 |
|
in installing the home in the manufactured home park and that have | 147 |
|
not been reimbursed by another tenant or owner. | 148 |
| (I) If the park operator violates any provision of divisions | 149 |
|
(A) to (H) of this section, the tenant or owner may recover actual | 150 |
|
damages resulting from the violation, and, if the tenant or owner | 151 |
|
obtains a judgment, reasonable attorneys' fees, or terminate the | 152 |
|
rental agreement. | 153 |
| (J) No rental agreement shall require a tenant or owner to | 154 |
|
sell, lease, or sublet the tenant's or owner's interest in the | 155 |
|
rental agreement or the manufactured or mobile home that is or | 156 |
|
will be located on the lot that is the subject of the rental | 157 |
|
agreement to any specific person or through any specific person as | 158 |
|
the person's agent. | 159 |
| (K) No park operator shall enter into a rental agreement with | 160 |
|
the owner of a manufactured or mobile home for the use of | 161 |
|
residential premises, if the rental agreement requires the owner | 162 |
|
of the home, as a condition to the owner's renting, occupying, or | 163 |
|
remaining on the residential premises, to pay the park operator or | 164 |
|
any other person specified in the rental agreement a fee or any | 165 |
|
sum of money based on the sale of the home, unless the owner of | 166 |
|
the home uses the park operator or other person as the owner's | 167 |
|
agent in the sale of the home. | 168 |
| (L) A park operator and a tenant or owner may include in a | 169 |
|
rental agreement any terms and conditions, including any term | 170 |
|
relating to rent, the duration of an agreement, and any other | 171 |
|
provisions governing the rights and obligations of the parties | 172 |
|
that are not inconsistent with or prohibited by sections 3733.09 | 173 |
|
to 3733.20 of the Revised Code or any other rule of law. | 174 |
| (M) Notwithstanding any other provision of the Revised Code, | 175 |
|
the owner of a manufactured or mobile home that was previously | 176 |
|
titled by a dealer may utilize the services of a manufactured home | 177 |
|
dealer licensed under Chapter 4517. of the Revised Code or a | 178 |
|
person properly licensed under Chapter 4735. of the Revised Code | 179 |
|
to sell or lease the home. | 180 |
| Sec. 5301.072. (A) No covenant, condition, or restriction set | 181 |
|
forth in a deed, and no rule, regulation, bylaw, or other | 182 |
|
governing document or agreement of a homeowners, neighborhood, | 183 |
|
civic, or other association, shall prohibit or be construed to | 184 |
prohibit theany of the following: | 185 |
| (1) The placement on any property of a flagpole that is to be | 186 |
used for the purpose of displaying, or shall prohibit or be | 187 |
construed to prohibit the flag of the United States; | 188 |
(2) The display on any property of, the flag of the United | 189 |
|
States if the flag is displayed in accordance with any of the | 190 |
|
following: | 191 |
(1)(a) The patriotic customs set forth in 4 U.S.C.A. 5-10, as | 192 |
|
amended, governing the display and use of the flag of the United | 193 |
|
States; | 194 |
(2)(b) The consent of the property's owner or of any person | 195 |
|
having lawful control of the property; | 196 |
(3)(c) The recommended flagpole standards set forth in "Our | 197 |
|
Flag," published pursuant to S.C.R. 61 of the 105th Congress, 1st | 198 |
|
Session (1998); | 199 |
(4)(d) Any federal law, proclamation of the president of the | 200 |
|
United States or the governor, section of the Revised Code, or | 201 |
|
local ordinance or resolution. | 202 |
| (3) The display of a service flag approved by the United | 203 |
|
States secretary of defense for display in a window of the | 204 |
|
residence of a member of the immediate family of an individual | 205 |
|
serving in the armed forces of the United States. A service flag | 206 |
|
includes a blue star banner, a gold star banner, and any other | 207 |
|
flag the secretary of defense designates as a service flag. | 208 |
| (B) A covenant, condition, restriction, rule, regulation, | 209 |
|
bylaw, governing document, or agreement or a construction of any | 210 |
|
of these items that violates division (A) of this section is | 211 |
|
against public policy and unenforceable in any court of this state | 212 |
|
to the extent it violates that division. | 213 |
| Sec. 5311.191. (A) No declaration, bylaw, rule, regulation, | 214 |
|
or agreement of a condominium property or construction of any of | 215 |
|
these items by the board of managers of its unit owners | 216 |
association shall prohibit theeither of the following: | 217 |
| (1) The placement of a flagpole that is to be used for the | 218 |
purpose of displaying, or shall prohibit the display of, the flag | 219 |
|
of the United States on or within the limited common areas and | 220 |
|
facilities of a unit owner or on the immediately adjacent exterior | 221 |
|
of the building in which the unit of a unit owner is located, if | 222 |
|
the flag is displayed in accordance with any of the following: | 223 |
(1)(a) The patriotic customs set forth in 4 U.S.C.A. 5-10, as | 224 |
|
amended, governing the display and use of the flag of the United | 225 |
|
States; | 226 |
(2)(b) The recommended flagpole standards set forth in "Our | 227 |
|
Flag," published pursuant to S.C.R. 61 of the 105th Congress, 1st | 228 |
|
Session (1998); | 229 |
(3)(c) Any federal law, proclamation of the president of the | 230 |
|
United States or the governor, section of the Revised Code, or | 231 |
|
local ordinance or resolution. | 232 |
| (2) The display of a service flag approved by the United | 233 |
|
States secretary of defense for display in a window of the | 234 |
|
residence of a member of the immediate family of an individual | 235 |
|
serving in the armed forces of the United States. A service flag | 236 |
|
includes a blue star banner, a gold star banner, and any other | 237 |
|
flag the secretary of defense designates as a service flag. | 238 |
| (B) A declaration, bylaw, rule, regulation, or agreement or | 239 |
|
the construction of any of these items that violates division (A) | 240 |
|
of this section is against public policy and unenforceable in any | 241 |
|
court of this state to the extent it violates that division. | 242 |
| Sec. 5321.131. (A) No landlord shall include any restriction | 243 |
|
in a rental agreement, or otherwise prohibit on a tenant's rental | 244 |
|
property, either of the following: | 245 |
| (1) The display of the flag of the United States if the flag | 246 |
|
is displayed in accordance with any of the following: | 247 |
| (a) The patriotic customs set forth in 4 U.S.C.A. 5-10, as | 248 |
|
amended, governing the display and use of the flag of the United | 249 |
|
States; | 250 |
| (b)Federal law, state law, or any local ordinance or | 251 |
|
resolution; | 252 |
| (c) A proclamation of the president of the United States or | 253 |
|
the governor of the state. | 254 |
| (2) The display of a service flag approved by the United | 255 |
|
States secretary of defense for display in a window of the | 256 |
|
residence of a member of the immediate family of an individual | 257 |
|
serving in the armed forces of the United States. A service flag | 258 |
|
includes a blue star banner, a gold star banner, and any other | 259 |
|
flag the secretary of defense designates as a service flag. | 260 |
| (B) Any violation of this section is against public policy | 261 |
|
and unenforceable. Any provision of a rental agreement that | 262 |
|
violates this section is an unconscionable term under section | 263 |
|
5321.14 of the Revised Code. | 264 |
| Section 2. That existing sections 3733.11, 5301.072, and | 265 |
|
5311.191 of the Revised Code are hereby repealed. | 266 |
