Bill Text: NY S09120 | 2023-2024 | General Assembly | Introduced


Bill Title: Relates to adopting the Appalachian states radioactive waste compact; assures interstate cooperation for the proper management and disposal of low-level radioactive wastes to reduce the volume of low-level radioactive waste.

Spectrum: Partisan Bill (Democrat 1-0)

Status: (Introduced) 2024-04-29 - REFERRED TO ENVIRONMENTAL CONSERVATION [S09120 Detail]

Download: New_York-2023-S09120-Introduced.html



                STATE OF NEW YORK
        ________________________________________________________________________

                                          9120

                    IN SENATE

                                     April 29, 2024
                                       ___________

        Introduced  by  Sen. SKOUFIS -- read twice and ordered printed, and when
          printed to be committed to the Committee on Environmental Conservation

        AN ACT to amend the  environmental  conservation  law,  in  relation  to
          adopting the Appalachian states radioactive waste compact

          The  People of the State of New York, represented in Senate and Assem-
        bly, do enact as follows:

     1    Section 1. Article 21 of the environmental conservation law is amended
     2  by adding a new title 2 to read as follows:
     3                                   TITLE 2
     4                APPALACHIAN STATES RADIOACTIVE WASTE COMPACT
     5       Section 21-0201. Appalachian states radioactive waste compact.
     6    § 21-0201. Appalachian states radioactive waste compact. 1. The  appa-
     7  lachian  states  radioactive  waste  compact  is hereby entered into and
     8  enacted into law with all jurisdictions legally joining therein, in  the
     9  form substantially as follows:
    10                                  Article 1
    11                                 Definitions
    12    As  used  in this compact, unless the context clearly indicated other-
    13  wise:
    14    (a) "Broker" means any intermediate person who handles, treats,  proc-
    15  esses,  stores,  packages,  ships or otherwise has responsibility for or
    16  possesses low-level waste obtained from a generator.
    17    (b) "Carrier" means a person  who  transports  low-level  waste  to  a
    18  regional facility.
    19    (c)  "Commission"  means  the Appalachian States Low-Level Radioactive
    20  Waste Commission.
    21    (d) "Disposal"  means  the  isolation  of  low-level  waste  from  the
    22  biosphere.
    23    (e)  "Facility" means any real or personal property within the region,
    24  and improvements thereof or thereon, and any and all  plant  structures,
    25  machinery  and  equipment  acquired, constructed, operated or maintained
    26  for the management or disposal of low-level waste.
    27    (f) "Generate" means to produce low-level waste requiring disposal.

         EXPLANATION--Matter in italics (underscored) is new; matter in brackets
                              [ ] is old law to be omitted.
                                                                   LBD13933-02-4

        S. 9120                             2

     1    (g)  "Generator"  means  a  person  whose  activity  results  in   the
     2  production of low-level waste requiring disposal.
     3    (h) "Hazardous Life" means the time required for radioactive materials
     4  to  decay  to safe levels, as defined by the time period for the concen-
     5  tration of radioactive materials within a given container or package  to
     6  decay to maximum permissible concentrations as defined by Federal law or
     7  by standards to be set by a host state, whichever is more restrictive.
     8    (i) "Host state" means Pennsylvania or other party state so designated
     9  by the Commission in accordance with Article 3 of this compact.
    10    (j)  "Institutional  control  period"  means the time of the continued
    11  observation, monitoring and care  of  the  regional  facility  following
    12  transfer of control from the operator to the custodial agency.
    13    (k) "Low-level waste" means radioactive waste that:
    14    (1) is neither high-level waste or transuranic waste, nor spent nucle-
    15  ar  fuel, nor by-product material as defined in Section 1 1(e)(2) of the
    16  Atomic Energy Act of 1954 as amended; and
    17    (2) is classified  by  the  Federal  Government  as  low-level  waste,
    18  consistent  with existing law; but does not include waste generated as a
    19  result of atomic energy defense activities of the Federal Government, as
    20  defined in Public Law 96-573, or Federal research and development activ-
    21  ities.
    22    (l) "Management" means the reduction, collection, consolidation, stor-
    23  age, packaging or treatment of low-level waste.
    24    (m) "Operator" means a person who operates a regional facility.
    25    (n) "Party state" means any state that has become a party  in  accord-
    26  ance with Article 5 of this compact.
    27    (o)  "Person"  means  an individual, corporation, partnership or other
    28  legal entity, whether public or private.
    29    (p) "Region" means the combined geographical area within  the  bounda-
    30  ries of the party states.
    31    (q)  "Regional facility" means a facility within any party state which
    32  has been approved by the commission for the disposal of low-level waste.
    33    (r) "Shallow land burial" means the disposal of low-level  radioactive
    34  waste  directly in subsurface trenches without additional confinement in
    35  engineered structures or by proper packaging in containers as determined
    36  by the law of the host state.
    37    (s) "Transuranic waste" means low-level waste containing radionuclides
    38  with an atomic number greater than 92 which are excluded  from  shallow-
    39  land burial by the Federal Government.
    40                                  Article 2
    41                               The Commission
    42  (A) Creation and Organization
    43    (1) Creation--There is hereby created the Appalachian States Low-Level
    44  Radioactive Waste Commission. The Commission is hereby created as a body
    45  corporate and politic, with succession for the duration of this compact,
    46  as  an  agency  and instrumentality of the governments of the respective
    47  signatory parties, but separate and distinct from the respective  signa-
    48  tory  party states. The Commission shall have central offices located in
    49  Pennsylvania.
    50    (2) Commission Membership--The Commission shall consist of two  voting
    51  members  from  each party state to be appointed according to the laws of
    52  each party state and two additional voting members from each host  state
    53  to be appointed according to the laws of each host state. Upon selection
    54  of  the site of the regional facility, an additional voting member shall
    55  be appointed to the Commission who shall be a resident of the county  or
    56  municipality where the facility is to be located. The appointing author-

        S. 9120                             3

     1  ity  of  each  party state shall notify the Commission in writing of the
     2  identities of the members and of any alternates. An alternate  may  vote
     3  and act in the member's absence. No member shall have a financial inter-
     4  est  in  any  industry  which generates low-level radioactive waste, any
     5  low-level radioactive waste regional facility or  any  related  industry
     6  for the duration of the member's term. No more than one-half the members
     7  and  alternates  from  any party state shall have been employed by or be
     8  employed by  a  low-level  waste  generator  or  related  industry  upon
     9  appointment  to  or  during  their  tenure  of office; provided, that no
    10  member shall have been employed by or be employed by a regional facility
    11  operator. No member or alternate  from  any  party  state  shall  accept
    12  employment  from  any regional facility operator or brokers for at least
    13  three years after leaving office.
    14    (3) Compensation--Members of the Commission and alternates shall serve
    15  without compensation from the  Commission  but  may  be  reimbursed  for
    16  necessary  expenses incurred in and incident to the performance of their
    17  duties.
    18    (4) Voting Power-Each Commission  member  is  entitled  to  one  vote.
    19  Unless otherwise provided in this compact, affirmative votes by a major-
    20  ity  of  a host state's members are necessary for the Commission to take
    21  any action related to the regional facility and the disposal and manage-
    22  ment of low-level waste within that host state.
    23    (5) Organization and Procedure--
    24    (a) The Commission shall provide for its own organization  and  proce-
    25  dures and shall adopt by-laws not inconsistent with this compact and any
    26  rules and regulations necessary to implement this compact. It shall meet
    27  at  least once a year in the county selected to host a regional facility
    28  and shall elect a chairman and vice chairman from among its members.  In
    29  the absence of the chairman, the vice chairman shall serve.
    30    (b) All meetings of the Commission shall be open to the public with at
    31  least  14  days' advance notice, except that the chairman may convene an
    32  emergency meeting with less advance notice. Each municipality and county
    33  selected to host a regional facility shall be specifically  notified  in
    34  advance of all Commission meetings. All meetings of the Commission shall
    35  be  conducted in a manner that substantially conforms to the Administra-
    36  tive Procedure Act (5 U.S.C. Ch.5, Subch.1I, and Ch.'7). The  Commission
    37  may, by a two-thirds vote, including approval of a majority of each host
    38  state's  Commission  members,  hold  an  Executive Session closed to the
    39  public for the purpose of: considering or discussing legally  privileged
    40  or  proprietary  information;  to consider dismissal, disciplining of or
    41  hearing complaints or charges  brought  against  an  employee  or  other
    42  public  agent  unless  such  person  requests such public hearing; or to
    43  consult  with  its  attorney  regarding  information  or   strategy   in
    44  connection  with  specific  litigation.  The  reason  for  the Executive
    45  Session must he announced at  least  14  days  prior  to  the  Executive
    46  Session,  except that the chairman may convene an emergency meeting with
    47  less advance notice, in which case the reason for the Executive  Session
    48  must  be  announced  at  the  open meeting immediately-subsequent to the
    49  Executive Session. All action taken in violation of  this  open  meeting
    50  provision shall be null and void.
    51    (c)  Detailed  written  minutes  shall  be kept of all meetings of the
    52  Commission. All decisions, files, records and data  of  the  Commission,
    53  except  for  information  privileged  against  introduction  in judicial
    54  proceedings, personnel records and minutes of a properly convened Execu-
    55  tive Session, shall be open to public inspection subject to a  procedure
    56  that  substantially  conforms  to the Freedom of Information Act (Public

        S. 9120                             4

     1  Law 89-554, 5 U.S.C. § 552) and applicable Pennsylvania law and  may  be
     2  copied  upon  request  and payment of fees which shall be no higher than
     3  necessary to recover copying costs.
     4    (d)  The  Commission  shall  select an appropriate staff, including an
     5  Executive Director, to carry out the duties and  functions  assigned  by
     6  the  Commission. Notwithstanding any other provision of law, the Commis-
     7  sion may hire and/or retain its own legal counsel.
     8    (e) Any person aggrieved by a final decision of the  Commission  which
     9  adversely  affects the legal rights, duties or privileges of such person
    10  may petition a court of competent jurisdiction, within 60 days after the
    11  Commission's final decision, to obtain judicial  review  of  said  final
    12  decisions.
    13    (f)  Liabilities  of the Commission shall not be deemed liabilities of
    14  the party states. Members of the  Commission  shall  not  be  personally
    15  liable for actions taken in their official capacity.
    16  B. Powers and Duties
    17  The Commission:
    18    (a)  Shall  conduct  research  and  establish regulations to promote a
    19  reasonable reduction of volume and curie  content  of  low-level  wastes
    20  generated  in  the  region.  The  regulations  shall be reviewed and, if
    21  necessary, revised by the Commission at least annually.
    22    (b) Shall ensure, to the extent authorized by Federal law,  that  low-
    23  level  wastes  are  safely disposed of within the region except that the
    24  Commission shall have no power or  authority  to  license,  regulate  or
    25  otherwise  develop  a regional facility, such powers and authority being
    26  reserved for the host state(s) as permitted under the law.
    27    (c) Shall designate as "host states" any party state  which  generates
    28  25  percent  or  more of Pennsylvania's volume or total curie content of
    29  low-level waste generated based on a comparison of averages  over  three
    30  successive  years,  as  determined by the Commission. This determination
    31  shall be based on volume or total curie content, whichever is greater.
    32    (d) Shall ensure, to the extent authorized by Federal law,  that  low-
    33  level  waste  packages  brought  into the regional facility for disposal
    34  conform to applicable state and  Federal  regulations.  Low-level  waste
    35  brokers or generators who violate these regulations will be subject to a
    36  fine  or  other  penalty imposed by the Commission, including restricted
    37  access to a regional facility. The  Commission  may  impose  such  fines
    38  and/or  penalties  in  addition to any other penalty levied by the party
    39  states pursuant to Article 4(D).
    40    (e) Shall establish such advisory committees as it deems necessary for
    41  the purpose of advising the Commission  on  matters  pertaining  to  the
    42  management and disposal of low-level waste.
    43    (f)  May  contract  to accomplish its duties and effectuate its powers
    44  subject to projected  available  resources.  No  contract  made  by  the
    45  Commission shall bind a party state.
    46    (g)  Shall  prepare  contingency  plans for management and disposal of
    47  low-level waste in the event any regional facility should be  closed  or
    48  otherwise unavailable.
    49    (h)  Shall  examine  all  records  of operators of regional facilities
    50  pertaining to operating costs, profits or the assessment  or  collection
    51  of any charge, fee or surcharge and may make recommendations to the host
    52  state(s)  which  shall review the recommendations in accordance with its
    53  (their) own sovereign laws.
    54    (i) Shall have the power  to  sue  and  be  sued  subject  to  Article
    55  2(A)(5)(e)  and  may seek to intervene in any administrative or judicial
    56  proceeding.

        S. 9120                             5

     1    (j) Shall assemble and make available, to the party states and to  the
     2  public,  information  concerning low-level waste management and disposal
     3  needs, technologies and problems.
     4    (k)  Shall  keep  current  and annual inventories of all generators by
     5  name and quantity of low-level waste generated within the region,  based
     6  upon  information  provided  by  the party states. Inventory information
     7  shall include both volume in cubic feet and total curie content  of  the
     8  low-level  waste  and  all available information on chemical composition
     9  and toxicity of such wastes.
    10    (l) Shall keep an inventory of all regional facilities and specialized
    11  facilities, including, but not necessarily restricted to, information on
    12  their size, capacity and location, as well as specific wastes capable of
    13  being managed, and the projected useful life of each regional facility.
    14    (m) Shall make and publish an annual report to the  governors  of  the
    15  signatory  party  states and to the public detailing its programs, oper-
    16  ations and finances, including copies of the annual budget and the inde-
    17  pendent audit required by this compact.
    18    (n) Notwithstanding any other provision of this compact to the contra-
    19  ry, may, with the unanimous approval of the Commission  members  of  the
    20  host  state(s), enter into temporary agreements with non-party states or
    21  other regional boards for the emergency disposal of low-level  waste  at
    22  the  regional facility, if so authorized by law(s) of the host state(s),
    23  or other disposal facilities located in states that are not  parties  to
    24  this agreement.
    25    (o)  Shall  promulgate  regulations,  pursuant  to  host state law, to
    26  specifically govern and define exactly what would constitute an emergen-
    27  cy situation and exactly what  restrictions  and  limitations  would  be
    28  placed on temporary agreements.
    29    (p) Shall not accept any donations, grants, equipment, supplies, mate-
    30  rials  or  services,  conditional  or otherwise, from any source, except
    31  from any Federal agency and from party states  which  are  certified  as
    32  being legal and proper under the laws of the donating party state.
    33  (C) Budget and Operation
    34    (1)  Fiscal  Year - The Commission shall establish a fiscal year which
    35  conforms to the fiscal year of the Commonwealth of Pennsylvania.
    36    (2) Current Expense  Budget  -  Upon  legislative  enactment  of  this
    37  compact  by  two  party states and each year until the regional facility
    38  becomes available, the Commission shall adopt a current  expense  budget
    39  for its fiscal year. The budget shall include the Commission's estimated
    40  expenses  for  administration.  Such  expenses shall be allocated to the
    41  party states according to the following formula:
    42    Each designated initial host state will be allocated  costs  equal  to
    43  twice  the  costs  of  the  other  party states, but such costs will not
    44  exceed $200,000.
    45    Each remaining party state will be allocated a cost of  one  half  the
    46  cost of the initial host state, but such costs will not exceed $100,000.
    47  The  party  states  will  include  the  amounts allocated above in their
    48  respective budgets, subject to  such  review  and  approval  as  may  be
    49  required  by their respective budgetary processes. Such amounts shall be
    50  due and payable to the Commission in quarterly installments  during  the
    51  fiscal year.
    52    (3)  Annual  Budget  Request - For continued funding of its activities
    53  the Commission shall submit an annual budget request to each party state
    54  for funding, based upon the percentage of the region's  waste  generated
    55  in  each state in the region, as reported in the latest available annual
    56  inventory required under Article 2(B)(k). The percentage of waste  shall

        S. 9120                             6

     1  be  based on volume of waste or total curie content as determined by the
     2  Commission.
     3    (4) Annual Report to Include Budget - The Commission shall prepare and
     4  include  in  the annual report a budget showing anticipated receipts and
     5  disbursements for the ensuing year.
     6    (5) Annual Independent Audit--
     7    (a) As soon as practicable after the closing of the  fiscal  year,  an
     8  audit  shall  be  made  of the financial accounts of the Commission. The
     9  audit shall be made by qualified certified public  accountants  selected
    10  by  the  Commission, who have no personal direct or indirect interest in
    11  the financial affairs of the  Commission  or  any  of  its  officers  or
    12  employees.    The  report  of audit shall be prepared in accordance with
    13  accepted accounting practices and shall be filed with the  chairman  and
    14  such other officers as the Commission shall direct. Copies of the report
    15  shall  be distributed to each Commission member and shall be made avail-
    16  able for public distribution.
    17    (b) Each signatory party, by its duly authorized  officers,  shall  be
    18  entitled  to  examine and audit at any time all of the books, documents,
    19  records, files and accounts and all other papers, things or property  of
    20  the  Commission. The representatives of the signatory parties shall have
    21  access to all books, documents, records, accounts,  reports,  files  and
    22  all  other  papers,  things  or  property  belonging to or in use by the
    23  Commission and necessary to facilitate the  audit;  and  they  shall  be
    24  afforded full facilities for verifying transactions with the balances or
    25  securities held by depositaries, fiscal agents and custodians.
    26                                  Article 3
    27          Rights, Responsibilities and Obligations of Party States
    28    (A) Regional Facilities
    29    There  shall  be regional facilities sufficient to dispose of the low-
    30  level waste generated within the region. Each regional facility shall be
    31  capable of disposing of such low-level waste but in the form(s) required
    32  by regulations or license conditions. Specialized facilities for partic-
    33  ular types of low-level waste management, reduction or treatment may not
    34  be developed in any party state unless they are in accordance  with  the
    35  laws and regulations of such state and applicable Federal laws and regu-
    36  lations.
    37    (B) Equal Access to Regional Facilities
    38    Each  party  state  shall  have  equal access as other party states to
    39  regional facilities located within the region  and  accepting  low-level
    40  waste,  provided,  however,  that  the host state may close the regional
    41  facility located within its borders when necessary for public health and
    42  safety. However, a host state shall send notification to the  Commission
    43  in  writing within three (3) days of its action and shall, within thirty
    44  (30) working days, provide in writing the reasons for the closing.
    45  (C) Initial Host State
    46  Pennsylvania and party states which generated 25 percent or more of  the
    47  volume  or curies of low-level waste generated by Pennsylvania, based on
    48  a comparison of averages over the three years  1982  through  1984,  are
    49  designated as "initial host states" and are required to develop and host
    50  low-level  waste  sites  as regional facilities. The percentage of waste
    51  from each state shall be determined by cubic foot volume or total  curie
    52  content, whichever is greater.
    53    (D) Exemption From Being Initial Host Site
    54  Party  states  which  generated  less  than  25 percent of the volume or
    55  curies of low-level waste generated by Pennsylvania, based on a  compar-
    56  ison  of averages over the years 1982 through 1984, shall be exempt from

        S. 9120                             7

     1  initial host state responsibilities. These states shall continue  to  be
     2  exempt  as long as they generate less than the 25 percent threshold over
     3  successive 3-year periods. Once a  state  generates  an  average  of  25
     4  percent or more of the volume or curies generated by Pennsylvania over a
     5  successive 3-year period, it shall be designated as a "host state" for a
     6  30-year period by the Commission and shall immediately initiate develop-
     7  ment,  of  a regional facility to be operational within five years. Such
     8  host state shall be prepared to accept at its regional facility low-lev-
     9  el waste at least equal to that generated in the state. With  Commission
    10  approval, any party state may volunteer to host a regional facility. The
    11  percentage  of  waste  from  each  state shall be determined by either a
    12  cubic foot volume or total curie content, whichever is greater.
    13    (E) Useful Life of Regional Facilities
    14  Pennsylvania and other host states are  obligated  to  develop  regional
    15  facilities  for  the  duration  of this compact. All regional facilities
    16  shall be designed for at least a 30-year useful life. At the end of  the
    17  facility's  life,  normal  closure  and  maintenance procedures shall be
    18  initiated in accordance with the applicable  requirements  of  the  host
    19  state and the Federal Government. Each host state's obligation for oper-
    20  ating regional facilities shall remain as long as the state continues to
    21  produce  over a 3-year period 25 percent or more of the volume or curies
    22  of low-level waste generated by Pennsylvania.
    23  (F) Duties of Host State
    24  Each host state shall:
    25    (a) Cause a regional facility to be sited and developed  on  a  timely
    26  basis
    27    (b)  Ensure  by law, consistent with applicable state and Federal law,
    28  the protection and preservation of public health,  safety  and  environ-
    29  mental  quality  in  the siting, design, development, licensure or other
    30  regulation, operation, closure, decommissioning, long-term care and  the
    31  institutional  control period of the regional facility within the state.
    32  To the extent authorized by Federal law, a host  state  may  adopt  more
    33  stringent laws, rules or regulations than required by Federal law.
    34    (c)  Ensure  and maintain a manifest system which documents all waste-
    35  related activities of generators, brokers, carriers and  related  activ-
    36  ities  of generators, brokers, carriers and operators, and establish the
    37  chain of custody of waste from its initial generation to the end of  its
    38  hazardous  life.  Copies of all such manifests shall be submitted to the
    39  Commission on a timely basis.
    40    (d) Ensure that  charges  for  disposal  of  low-level  waste  at  the
    41  regional  facility  are  sufficient  to fully fund the safe disposal and
    42  perpetual care of the regional facility and that  charges  are  assessed
    43  without discrimination as to the party state of origin.
    44    (e)  Submit  an  annual  report to the Commission on the status of the
    45  regional facility which contains projections of the  anticipated  future
    46  capacity.
    47    (f) Notify the Commission immediately if any exigency arises requiring
    48  the possible temporary or permanent closure of a regional facility with-
    49  in  the  state  at a time earlier than was projected in the state's most
    50  recent annual report to the Commission.
    51    (g) Require that the institutional  control  period  of  any  disposal
    52  facility  be at least as long as the hazardous life, as defined in Arti-
    53  cle 1(h), of the radioactive materials that are disposed at that facili-
    54  ty.

        S. 9120                             8

     1    (h) Prohibit the use of any shallow land burial, as defined in Article
     2  1(r), and develop alternative means for treatment, storage and  disposal
     3  of low-level waste.
     4    (i)  Establish  by  law,  to the extent not prohibited by Federal law,
     5  requirements for financial responsibility, including,  but  not  limited
     6  to:
     7    (i)  Requirements  for the purchase and maintenance of adequate insur-
     8  ance by generators, brokers, carriers  and  operators  of  the  regional
     9  facility;
    10    (ii) Requirements for the establishment of a long-term care fund to be
    11  funded  by a fee placed on generators to pay for preventative or correc-
    12  tive measures of low-level waste to the regional facility; and
    13    (iii) Any further financial responsibility requirements that shall  be
    14  submitted  by  generators,  brokers,  carriers  and  operators as deemed
    15  necessary by the host state.
    16  (G) Duties of Party State
    17  Each party state:
    18    (a) Shall appropriate its portion  of  the  Commission's  initial  and
    19  annual budget as set out in Article 2(C)(2) and (3).
    20    (b) To the extent authorized by Federal law, shall develop and enforce
    21  procedures  requiring  low-level  waste shipments originating within its
    22  borders and destined for  a  regional  facility  to  conform  to  volume
    23  reduction,  packaging and transportation requirements and regulations as
    24  well as any other requirements specified by the regional facility.  Such
    25  procedures shall include, but are not limited to:
    26    (i) Periodic inspections of packaging and shipping practices
    27    (ii)  Periodic  inspections  of  low-level  waste  containers while in
    28  custody of carriers; and
    29    (iii) Appropriate enforcement actions with respect to violations
    30    (c) To the extent authorized by Federal law,  shall,  after  receiving
    31  notification  from a host state or other person that a person in a party
    32  state has violated volume reduction, packaging, shipping or  transporta-
    33  tion requirements or regulations, take appropriate action to ensure-that
    34  violations  do  not  recur. Appropriate action shall include, but is not
    35  limited to, the requirement that a bond be posted by the violator to pay
    36  the cost of repackaging at the regional  facility  and  the  requirement
    37  that  future shipments be inspected. Appropriate action may also include
    38  suspension of the violator's use of the regional facility.  Should  such
    39  suspension  be imposed, the suspension shall remain in effect until such
    40  time as the violator has, to the satisfaction of the party state  impos-
    41  ing such suspension, complied with the appropriate requirements or regu-
    42  lations  upon  which  the suspension was based and has taken appropriate
    43  action to ensure that such violation or violations do not recur.
    44    (d) Shall maintain a registry of all generators and quantities  gener-
    45  ated within the state.
    46    (H) Liability
    47    In  the  event of liability arising from the operation of any regional
    48  facility and during and after closure of that facility, each party state
    49  shall share in that liability in an amount equal to that  state's  share
    50  of  the  region's  low-level  waste disposed of at the facility. If such
    51  liability arises from negligence, malfeasance or neglect on the part  of
    52  a  host  state or any party state, then any other host or party state(s)
    53  may make any claim allowable under law for that negligence,  malfeasance
    54  or neglect. If such liability arises from a particular waste shipment or
    55  shipments to, or quantity of waste or condition at, the regional facili-
    56  ty,  then any host or party state may make any claim allowable under law

        S. 9120                             9

     1  for such liability. The percentage of waste shall be based on volume  of
     2  waste or total curie content.
     3    (I) Failure of Party State to Fulfill Obligations.
     4    A party state which fails to fulfill its obligations, including timely
     5  funding  of  the  Commission,  may have its privileges under the Compact
     6  suspended or its membership in the Compact revoked by the Commission and
     7  be subject to any other legal and equitable remedies  available  to  the
     8  party states.
     9                                  Article 4
    10                        Prohibited Acts and Penalties
    11    (A) Prohibition
    12    It  shall  be  unlawful  for  any person to dispose of low-level waste
    13  within the region except at a regional facility unless authorized by the
    14  Commission.
    15    (B) Waste Disposed of Within Region.
    16    After establishment of the regional facility(s), it shall be  unlawful
    17  for  any  person  to  dispose  of  any low-level waste within the region
    18  unless the waste was generated within the region or unless authorized to
    19  do so both by the Commission and by law of the host state in which  said
    20  disposal  takes place. For the purposes of this compact, waste generated
    21  within the region excludes radioactive material shipped from outside the
    22  party states to a waste management facility within the region. In deter-
    23  mining whether to grant such authorization, the factors to he considered
    24  by the Commission shall include, but not be limited to, the following:
    25    (a) The impact on health, safety, and  environmental  quality  of  the
    26  citizens of the party states;
    27    (b)  The  impact  of  importing  waste  on  the available capacity and
    28  projected life of the regional facility
    29    (c) The availability of a regional facility appropriate for  the  safe
    30  disposal of the type of low-level waste involved
    31    (C)  Waste  Generated Within Region Any and all low-level waste gener-
    32  ated within the region shall be disposed  of  at  a  regional  facility,
    33  except for specific cases agreed upon by the Commission, with the affir-
    34  mative  votes  by  a  majority  of  the  Commission  members of the host
    35  state(s) affected by the decision.
    36    (D) Liability.
    37    Generators, brokers and carriers of wastes, and owners  and  operators
    38  of sites shall be liable for their acts, omissions, conduct or relation-
    39  ships  in  accordance  with  all laws relating thereto. The party states
    40  shall impose a fine for any violation in an amount equal to the  present
    41  and  future  costs  associated  with  correcting  any harm caused by the
    42  violation and shall assess punitive fines or penalties if it  is  deemed
    43  necessary.    In  addition,  the  host  state  shall  bar any person who
    44  violates host state or  Federal  regulations  from  using  the  regional
    45  facility  until that person demonstrates to the satisfaction of the host
    46  state the ability and willingness to comply with the law.
    47    (E) Conflict of Interest.
    48    (1) Prohibitions--
    49    No commissioner, officer, or employer shall:
    50    (a) Be financially interested, either directly  or  indirectly,  in  a
    51  contract, sale, purchase, lease or transfer of real or personal property
    52  to which the Commission is a party.
    53    (b) Solicit or accept money or any other thing of value in addition to
    54  the expenses paid to him by the commission for services performed within
    55  the scope of his official duties.

        S. 9120                            10

     1    (c)  Offer  money  or  anything  of  value  for or in consideration of
     2  obtaining an appointment, promotion or privilege in his employment  with
     3  the Commission.
     4    (2) Forfeiture of Office of Employment -
     5    Any  officer  or  employee  who  shall  willfully  violate  any of the
     6  provisions of this section shall forfeit his office or employment.
     7    (3) Agreement Void -
     8    Any contract or agreement knowingly  made  in  contravention  of  this
     9  section is void.
    10    (4) Criminal and Civil Sanctions-
    11    Officers and employees of the Commission shall be subject, in addition
    12  to  the provisions of this section, to such criminal and civil sanctions
    13  for misconduct in office as may be imposed by Federal law and the law of
    14  the signatory state in which such misconduct occurs.
    15                                  Article 5
    16      Eligibility, Entry Into Effect, Congressional Consent, Withdrawal
    17    (A) Eligibility
    18  Only the States of Pennsylvania, West Virginia, Delaware,  and  Maryland
    19  are eligible to become parties to this compact.
    20    (B) Entry Into Effect
    21    An eligible state may become a party state by legislative enactment of
    22  this  compact  or  by  executive  order  of  the  governor adopting this
    23  compact; provided, however, a state becoming a party state by  executive
    24  order  shall  cease  to  be  a party state upon adjournment of the first
    25  general session of  its  legislature  convened  thereafter,  unless  the
    26  legislature shall have enacted this compact before such adjournment.
    27    (C) Congressional Consent
    28    This  compact shall take effect when it has been enacted by the legis-
    29  latures of Pennsylvania and one or more eligible states. However,  Arti-
    30  cle  4(B)  and (C) shall not take effect until Congress has consented to
    31  this compact. Every fifth  year  after  such  consent  has  been  given,
    32  Congress may withdraw consent.
    33    (D) Withdrawal
    34    A party state may withdraw from the compact by repealing the enactment
    35  of this compact, but no such withdrawal shall become effective until two
    36  years  after  enactment of the repealing legislation. If the withdrawing
    37  state is a host state, any regional facility in that state shall  remain
    38  available  to  receive low-level waste generated within the region until
    39  five years after the effective date of the withdrawal.
    40                                  Article 6
    41                        Construction and Severability
    42    (A) Construction
    43    The provisions of this compact shall be broadly  construed  to-  carry
    44  out  the  purposes  of  the compact, but the sovereign powers of a party
    45  state shall not unnecessarily be infringed.
    46    (B) Severability
    47    If any part or application  of  this  compact  is  held  invalid,  the
    48  remainder,  or  its application to other situation or persons, shall not
    49  be affected.
    50    § 2. This act shall take effect immediately.
feedback